On Tuesday’s The Lead with Jake Tapper on CNN, the present ran a report whining that West Virginia residents are harm by local weather change, however that, despite this, are against enacting radical, draconian authorities environmental rules. In fact, all of it got here again to complaining over the state’s reasonable Democratic Senator, Joe Manchin, additionally opposing such pricey insurance policies proposed in large left-wing laws on Capitol Hill.
Because the report blamed latest flooding within the state on world warming brought on by fossil fuels, information discovering that there has not been an total improve in world flooding lately was ignored.
Host Jake Tapper launched the report by treating it as a proven fact that the local weather change challenge is endangering West Virginia residents and making their climate worse:
Now, from Virginia to West Virginia, Democratic Senator Joe Manchin’s dwelling state. Manchin at present saying, “No method,” to yet one more local weather change provision within the President’s sweeping social applications bundle. Again dwelling in West Virginia, local weather change has grow to be a rising risk to West Virginians.
Establishing her pre-recorded piece, correspondent Rene Marsh lamented that Senator Manchin is reflecting the views of his constituents who’re in opposition to the Joe Biden administration’s push for extra rules:
Nicely, what I discovered, Jake, is that it is not simply Senator Manchin who would not need fast and aggressive motion on the subject of local weather change — it is a lot of his personal constituents who in actual time are feeling the impacts of local weather change. So we traveled there to peel again the layers and determine simply why local weather change is so difficult in that state.
Marsh then recounted report flooding that has hit the state lately, and hyped dire predictions concerning the future: “And this previous summer time, the hard-hit state noticed extra flooding from raging lethal floods to crimson drought, West Virginians over the previous few years have confronted climate whiplash, and scientists predict it should worsen.”
After noting a few of the devastation, she complained, “but Senator Joe Manchin is obstructing essentially the most aggressive local weather change laws in U.S. historical past.” Marsh famous Manchin’s ties to the fossil gasoline trade, and was then seen badgering the president of the West Virginia Coal Affiliation, accusing his commerce of being partly in charge for the state’s struggling: “Will you be okay realizing that West Virginia will proceed to get hit by extreme flooding (enhancing leap) as a result of we as a rustic did not curb greenhouse gases?”
Marsh didn’t inform viewers that information from latest years casts doubt on whether or not there’s a change in local weather that’s trending towards making flooding worse since there’s not a normal improve in such exercise internationally on common.
The piece ended with a soundbite of West Virginia College professor Nicholas Zegre, who discovered irony within the state’s residents resisting modifications although they might allegedly endure extra sooner or later within the absence of latest rules: “Local weather change is so difficult right here in West Virginia as a result of West Virginians understand it as a direct assault on their livelihoods. But it surely’s additionally attention-grabbing, too, that inaction of our enterprise leaders and inaction of our resolution makers can also be a direct assault on livelihoods.”
The report additionally ran on the identical day’s Don Lemon Tonight with the eponymous host declaring that the state “is getting hit arduous by the local weather disaster.”
This environmental alarmist propaganda on CNN’s The Lead was funded partially by T Cell. Their contact info is linked.
Full transcript follows:
CNN’s The Lead with Jake Tapper
October 19, 2021
5:39 p.m. Japanese
JAKE TAPPER: Now, from Virginia to West Virginia, Democratic Senator Joe Manchin’s dwelling state. Manchin at present saying, “No method,” to yet one more local weather change provision within the President’s sweeping social applications bundle. Again dwelling in West Virginia, local weather change has grow to be a rising risk to West Virginians. CNN’s Rene Marsh joins me now dwell. And, Rene, you traveled to West Virginia this week. What did you be taught from his constituents?
RENE MARSH: Nicely, what I discovered, Jake, is that it is not simply Senator Manchin who would not need fast and aggressive motion on the subject of local weather change — it is a lot of his personal constituents who in actual time are feeling the impacts of local weather change. So we traveled there to peel again the layers and determine simply why local weather change is so difficult in that state.
AUDIO OF 911 CALL #!: Our home is about to fall, and there is a set of infants right here and 1-2-3-4-5 adults.
AUDIO OF 911 CALL #2: We’re within the automotive, and the automotive’s flooding filled with water.
MARSH: Flood waters, submerged folks, automobiles and houses, dubbed the “thousand-year flood,” in Clendening, West Virginia, nearly wiped off the map in 2016. And this previous summer time, the hard-hit state noticed extra flooding from raging lethal floods to crimson drought, West Virginians over the previous few years have confronted climate whiplash, and scientists predict it should worsen. Jimmy Rader, a retired Iraq Struggle veteran, survived the lethal 2016 West Virginia flooding, however his dwelling didn’t. 5 years later, he’s nonetheless rebuilding. Within the meantime, he, his spouse and three canines name this camper dwelling.
JIMMY RADER, FLOODING SURVIVOR: It is actually robust with my PTSD being in such tight quarters.
MARSH: Look across the small West Virginia city of Clendening, and it is nonetheless with out a grocery retailer, financial institution and an elementary faculty, but Senator Joe Manchin is obstructing essentially the most aggressive local weather change laws in U.S. historical past. This neighborhood misplaced secure entry to their houses after the 2016 flood weakened the basis of this bridge and rusted it out. If somebody dialed 911, may not come throughout this bridge.
RADER: Yeah, they’d be afraid they would not make it, and the bridge would possibly collapse.
MARSH: This bridge is Connie Richard’s lifeline to on a regular basis life, together with medical care.
CONNIE RICHARD, WEST VIRGINIA RESIDENT: You simply hold transferring alongside and pray you get to the opposite facet.
MARSH: However even within the face of extreme climate and its pricey destruction, neither Rader nor Richard blame local weather change.
RADER: I am not shopping for into the entire local weather change factor.
MARSH: So if someone stated, “So as to make sure that a flood like this by no means hits your neighborhood once more — we have to eliminate coal,” what would you say?
RICHARD: Let if flood once more.
MARSH: Within the second largest coal-producing state within the nation, local weather change is a sophisticated challenge. Senator Joe Manchin, one of many key lawmakers blocking essentially the most aggressive elements of local weather laws that may drastically curb greenhouse emissions linked to local weather change, is at present ranked the highest congressional recipient of marketing campaign donations from the coal mining and fossil gasoline trade. Manchin’s private funding in Enersystems — a coal brokerage firm he based and later put in a blind belief — is valued between one and 5 million {dollars}.
MARSH (talking with West Virginia Coal Affiliation president Chris Hamilton): Will you be okay realizing that West Virginia will proceed to get hit by extreme flooding (enhancing leap) as a result of we as a rustic did not curb greenhouse gases?
CHRIS HAMILTON, WEST VIRGINIA COAL ASSOCIATION: I feel the premise is crammed with malarkey — I actually do. Now, once more, you understand, we’re delicate to the truth that, if we’re contributing towards local weather change, however you may’t blame each undesirable climate outcomes on West Virginia coal. We do not have severe droughts right here. We do not have severe fires right here. We’ve a bit little bit of flooding.
MARSH: The governor ordered a state of emergency as a result of there have been a number of counties going via droughts, and nearly each county in West Virginia has seen large flooding.
HAMILTON: But it surely’s very, very troublesome in charge that on coal as a result of (enhancing leap) once more we have cleaned up each airborne constituent. And, to the extent we’re contributing in direction of greenhouse gases, we’re doing the whole lot conceivable and humanly potential.
MARSH: Senator Manchin echoed this Monday.
MANCHIN: I wish to make sure that we’ve got dependable energy. We’ve mainly cleaned up the surroundings greater than another time within the historical past of this world.
MARSH: West Virginia College professor Nicholas Zegre has studied the state and local weather change for 11 years. He says breaking via the complexity of the difficulty feels unimaginable.
NICHOLAS ZEGRE, WEST VIRGINIA UNIVERSITY: Local weather change is so difficult right here in West Virginia as a result of West Virginians understand it as a direct assault on their livelihoods. But it surely’s additionally attention-grabbing, too, that inaction of our enterprise leaders and inaction of our resolution makers can also be a direct assault on livelihoods.
MARSH (dwell in studio): Now, coal — the underside line is coal could be very costly, there are cheaper power sources, and the trade is shedding jobs due to automation, Jake, however they’re hanging on to this dying trade. Many say the rationale for that’s merely due to undiversified economic system in West Virginia. So, you understand, even regardless of the influence of local weather change, you heard the folks in that piece say, “Let if flood.”
TAPPER: “Let if flood.” Once more, that was exceptional. Rene Marsh, glorious reporting, and it is so good to have you ever again.
About Post Author
