However, when the assault suspects’ mugshots were released on Sunday and Monday, critics noted that they all appeared to be white. The revelation played into a common criticism of antifa: While the movement justifies its embrace of violence in terms of self-defense against a supposed racist threat, its members appear to mostly hail from America’s white majority.
The irony was heightened in the case of the Portland demonstration because a mob of antifascist activists was filmed assaulting gay Asian journalist Andy Ngo, seemingly because of his critical coverage of their movement.
This was an Asian gay man attacked by an all white mob that purports to stand against Nazi. Only goes to show the left only pretends to care minorities that can be used as pawns to further their agenda.
Portland Police needs to be investigated by the DOJ. They support Antifa
— Melissa A. (@TheRightMelissa) June 30, 2019
One America News host Jack Posobiec concluded: “Antifa is white ISIS.”
Antifa is white ISIS pic.twitter.com/nSzARDFNeb
— Jack Posobiec 🇺🇸 (@JackPosobiec) June 30, 2019
Independent journalist Tim Pool deemed the movement to be “one of the largest white identitarian groups in the US.”
Antifa is one of the largest white identitarian groups in the US.
Albeit it is decentralized and they hate white people (themselves) but its still true.
— Tim Pool (@Timcast) July 1, 2019
Meanwhile, in an article entitled “Antifa Is Mostly Made Up of Privileged White Dudes,” The Federalist’s David Marcus argued that antifa’s racial makeup is in keeping with that of the left in general.
Antifa mugshots and far-left championing of minority causes
Conservative commentators have long blamed overeager whites for radicalizing the progressive movement in the name of minorities. David French made the case for National Review in a February essay.
“Change is fast, and there is no toleration for those left behind,” he wrote. “And ironically enough, a large part of this angry white activism is conducted on behalf of a black and brown population that is more moderate and more religious than their woke white champions. At a time when being a ‘white savior’ is seen as a mark of insensitivity — denying the power and autonomy of nonwhite Americans — white savioring is practically the mission statement of woke Twitter.”
Still, antifa activists and their supporters have stood by their self-defense narrative.
In an op-ed published Monday in Haaretz, Stanislav Vystosky, a critical sociologist at University of Wisconsin-Whitewater, claimed that “many militant anti-fascists” become activists “because aspects of their identity are directly targeted by fascist violence; they are queer, transgender, gender non-conforming, people of color, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs, and certainly identified in ways that intersected across these categories.”
According to Vystosky, antifa is a “means of ensuring their safety from a movement that threatens their very existence and venerates violence as the highest form of action.”
He claimed: “Even the Antifa activists who identify as cis heterosexual white males are the targets of fascist violence as ‘race’ and ‘gender’ traitors.”